Maturity profile
Assess seven practices for one outcome against the evidence you can show, then give the next improvement to an owner. Never added up into one number.
Ask each one of a single outcome.
Graded by what you can show, not by what you own.
- AbsentNothing exists.
- StatedWritten down, with an owner.
- In placeIt exists and runs.
- CheckedA recorded review by someone other than the person who did it, against a stated criterion. It doesn't mean every test passed, or that the review was independent.
- HeldStill true within its stated horizon, and reconfirmed after the last change.
- UnknownNobody can find out yet. A finding, never a zero.
Grades go down as well as up: when a horizon passes or something changes, the answer has to be shown again.
Everyone answers the same questions, but that doesn't make profiles comparable across organizations, or give them the same authority.
Details: when grades go down"Residents can pay their water bill online."
A three-person county IT shop, one outcome. Example data, not a real account.
| Practice | Grade | What the team can show |
|---|---|---|
| AimWhat must stay true, in what range, and who owns it? | Held | The aim is written down and owned by the utility director. It covers one budget year and was reconfirmed after the payment vendor changed. |
| MeasureHow will we know it's holding, and what decision does the number drive? | Stated | The measure is named, but no one has collected the numbers yet. |
| Evidence neededWhat do we have to see to know? | Stated | The team has listed what it needs: the vendor's settlement report and the import log. |
| CoverageDo we actually see it, and is what we see fresh? | Unknown | No one knows whether failed imports are logged. That gap is the main finding. |
| DetectionWhen it breaks, do we notice, and has that been tested? | Absent | Failures are only noticed when residents call. |
| Bounded workWho or what may act on it, within what limits, and who checks? | In place | Only the billing clerk can rerun an import, but no one reviews the reruns. |
| LoopDo we learn, and are repairs verified rather than assumed? | Absent | Problems are discussed when they happen, but nothing is written down. |
Grades, from least to most: Absent, Stated, In place, Checked, Held. Unknown means no one can find out yet; it is a finding, not a zero. What each grade means.
The next improvement
Find out whether failed imports are logged. The billing clerk does the work; the utility director owns the result.
A second example, a state agency with forty outcomes, is on the reference page.
Details: both examples, with full evidence